England’s designated national parks, celebrated for their breath taking landscapes and rich biodiversity, are coming under threat from a source often overlooked: pharmaceutical pollution. A report released on 13 August 2024 and spearheaded by the University of York has unveiled alarming levels of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) in the rivers flowing through these protected areas, raising concerns about their impact on both ecological and human health. Collectively and individually, we are all part of this problem.
The Silent Infiltration of APIs
The Broads and national parks in England are vital conservation areas that cover 9.3% of the country. Sites of Special Scientific Interest comprise about a quarter of this land - home to rare wildlife and sensitive ecosystems. Only 320,000 people live in England’s parks, (just 2% of them in the Broads Executive Area) but about 90 million visitors (Broads - 8 million) arrive each year to enjoy their treasures, soak up the tranquillity and diversity so often missing in people’s busy lives - and they bring their medicines with them.
The study monitored 54 APIs across 37 rivers in all ten areas over two seasons, winter and summer. The findings were startling: 31 different APIs were detected, contaminating 52 of the 54 monitoring sites, with drugs like metformin (used for diabetes), caffeine, and paracetamol showing the highest concentrations. Contamination was much higher in the summer tourist season.
We already know that sewer overflows, which are designed to release untreated wastewater to the environment during periods of extreme rainfall, are an important source of pharmaceuticals in surface waters, but this new evidence on the failure to deal with medicines entering the system in treated wastewater adds significantly to current worries. We already know that the wastewater treatment infrastructure in the Broads is not coping well with the needs of residents, far less with the influx of tourists. Staggering reports about contamination at Belaugh and between Horning and Ludham Bridge hit the headlines not long ago. Less is known about APIs from veterinary and agricultural sources, but these surely add to the contaminants in our waterways, as do pharmaceuticals wrongly disposed of in domestic rubbish or flushed down toilets.
Comparing National Parks and Urban Areas
While one might assume that rural landscapes are less polluted than urban rivers, the study reveals a more complex picture. Overall, API concentrations in the national parks were generally lower than in UK cities, but certain locations—particularly in the Peak District and Exmoor—showed higher concentrations than many urban rivers.
For instance, the Brook Head Stream in the Peak District and the River Exe in Exmoor had API levels that rivalled or exceeded those found in major cities. The study attributes these high levels to emissions from small wastewater treatment plants and storm overflows, which are often insufficiently equipped to remove pharmaceuticals effectively - a situation that may also pertain in the Broads.
While the published report doesn't focus specifically on the three sampling sites that were set up in the headwaters of the Wensum, Bure and Ant, it's evident that the thousands of septic tanks and package treatment works in these upper river catchments are discharging significant volumes of API-laden wastewater, which inevitably flows into the Broads.
Ecological and Human Health at Risk
The presence of APIs in these ecologically sensitive areas is concerning from two points of view. Firstly, the presence of antibiotics like clarithromycin and ciprofloxacin in rivers encourages the development of antimicrobial resistance. In protected areas like the Broads, where people are more likely to engage in recreational water activities such as swimming and splash sports, the risk of exposure to resistant bacteria can therefore be higher than is normally experienced in urban areas.
Secondly, pharmaceuticals are designed to interact with human biochemical pathways, but many of these are shared with other organisms, including fish, invertebrates, and algae. The York study found that concentrations of certain APIs, such as amitriptyline (an antidepressant) and propranolol (a heart medication), were high enough to pose risks to aquatic life, affecting everything from fish reproduction to the growth of water plants. Ibuprofen and methamphetamine have been linked to behavioural changes in fish, including addiction-like responses, reduced feeding activity, and impaired reproductive functions. They can even cause sex changes in some species. The long-term impact of these pollutants threatens the stability of aquatic ecosystems, highlighting the need for urgent action to protect vulnerable and sensitive wetland environments.
A Call for Action
The findings of this study underscore the urgent need for improved monitoring and management of pharmaceutical pollution in the Broads and national parks. The current monitoring and regulatory framework is highly variable and often not fit for purpose, with small wastewater treatment plants flying under the radar despite being significant sources of pollution, especially in areas with low water flow, where contaminants are less diluted.
Nature-based solutions, such as the creation of reedbeds that naturally filter out and break down pollutants, offer a promising way forward. These measures, along with stricter regulations and better maintenance of septic tanks, could help mitigate the impact of pharmaceutical pollution.
Areas like the Broads are not just scenic retreats; they are biodiversity hotspots that play a crucial role in preserving the country’s natural heritage. Protecting these areas from chemical contamination is vital if we are to ensure that they continue to thrive for generations to come. The study calls for a broader understanding of the threats posed by pharmaceutical pollution, not only here in the Broads, but across the whole of England.
As the pressures of modern life continue to encroach on even the most remote and protected landscapes, the need to address environmental pollution in all its forms has never been more urgent. We now know that pharmaceuticals are finding their way into the waterways of our most protected areas, impacting wildlife, and making those who come into direct contact with river water more vulnerable to ill-health. Only through concerted and collective effort can we hope fully to safeguard the ecological and human health of these treasured spaces, but each of us has our own part to play too. The Broads’ 6000 residents,12,500 boat-owners and 8 million visitors can help to ensure that wastewater and human sewage is properly disposed of, and that unwanted medicines are returned to pharmacies.
Sources and additional reading:
Comments